We started blogging about a year ago (more on that later this week), and one of our first posts was a recipe for Super Bowl Sliders. Since then, we tweaked the recipe a bit and figured since we are doing a “Super Bowl Snacks” series, we may as well post an update. But here is all you need to know; sliders are fun, perfect for entertaining kids and adults and taste great. And if you use our version of “Shake Shack” sauce, your sliders, or burgers, will be even better.
This sauce is our version of the special sauce from New York City’s favorite burger joint, the Shake Shack. Serious Eats reversed-engineered the sauce a few years ago (see here) and we tweaked it ever-so-slightly to go with our sliders. The key to the sauce, which is in the “1,000-island family” of sauces, is chopping up and blending dill or sour pickles (we use cornichons sometimes) directly into the sauce. The extra acidity and bite of the pickles along with mayo, ketchup, mustard, garlic powder, salt and paprika takes this sauce over the top. We use smoked paprika to add a touch of smokey flavor that does come through. In any event, make the sauce, trust us…
Otherwise, making sliders is just like making burgers, just smaller and faster. We make our sliders about 2 ounces (or a touch less) and make sure they are about 1/4 of an inch thick. We cook them in a very hot skillet or cast-iron pan for 2 minutes on one side, flip, add some cheese (just a little) and cook another minute for medium rare / medium. We set the sliders on a cutting board to rest for 5 minutes, this keeps the juices in the burger.
As for the bread, we use buttered and grilled dinner rolls like King Hawaiian (yes we love those rolls) or Parker House rolls. Taking the time to brown and heat the rolls is a nice touch and adds some buttery flavor to the mix. Then we just put the sliders on the rolls and top with the sauce. Simple, easy, and oh so tasty. And the small size means everyone can enjoy the sliders either as a snack or full meal. Just be ready to make another batch.
(Sauce adapted from Serious Eats)
What you get: Tasty, juicy sliders that can be served as snack, appetizer or main course.
What you need: No special equipment required. Good sharp pickles will help in the sauce.
How long? 30 minutes, max. Anytime dish.
(Makes 8 sliders, you will have extra sauce)
- 16 oz. ground chuck, formed into 8, 2 oz. patties that are less than ¼ inch thick
- 4 slices of American or cheddar cheese, tear into 8 pieces
- Salt and pepper
- 2 tablespoon bacon fat or vegetable oil
- 2 tablespoons butter
- 8 dinner rolls (King Hawaiian if you can get them)
- 1/2 cup mayonnaise
- 1 tablespoon ketchup
- 1 tablespoon yellow mustard
- 4 slices kosher dill pickle or cornichons, chopped
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder
- 1/4 teaspoon smoked paprika
- Pinch cayenne pepper
- Place all sauce ingredients into a food processor, blend until smooth (immersion blender will also work). Set aside.
- Split rolls and put a small amount of butter on each roll. (Optional: grill each roll, butter-side down, while you make the sliders for extra crunch and flavor).
- Heat a heavy skillet (cast iron is good here) over high heat. Make sure it is hot.
- Place 4 burgers in the skillet. Add pinch of salt and pepper to each burger. Cook for 2 minutes. Flip burger and add cheese. Cook another 1 minute. Set aside, under foil, to rest. Repeat with second batch of burgers.
- Place burgers on buns and add sauce, to taste. Serve.
- Beef and Blue Sliders (heatherlikesfood.com)
- Bite-Sized Super Bowl Snacks (redtri.com)
- Gridiron Grub: Winning Season Sliders (lasvegas.cbslocal.com)
- Touchdown Burger Slider Bar (frogprincepaperie.com)
- Ham and Cheese Soft Pretzel Roll Sliders (blogher.com)
- #DealAlert There Ain’t No Burger Like A Mark Burger… (smallchickbigdeals.com)
- Sky High Pulled Pork Sliders (lovebugandsweetiegirl.com)
- Super Bowl Snacks: Guacamole Revisited (putneyfarm.com)
Sliders are great for parties.
Indeed, somehow everyone enjoys them more than a big burger..
I swear you guys are trying to kill me this week – getting me drunk and stuffing me with sliders and spice cake.
We do our best….(worst?) 😉
I love sliders–fun for the whole family. I’m looking forward to making this sauce–I’ve got a few yellow squash pickles that the kids won’t eat because they are yellow, but the dill flavor is all there.
Hope you enjoy it! The sauce works on sandwiches like Reubens as well…
I would much rather have these than the Lean Cuisine I just had for lunch. they look so good – so juicy! I love sliders, and using King’s Hawaiian dinner rolls is genius!
Thanks…we would like to have these more…but “all things in moderation” (sigh) 😉
This is … food. Super bowl or not. We have a very likeness sauce to our hamburgers over here. I drool now. Sticky finger food. LOVE IT!!!!!
Thanks! These are fun. And the Super Bowl is just an excuse to make them!
I’ll own it: Hawaiian bread rocks! These sliders look divine too. Juicy and perfect!
We do seem to find plenty of reasons to use the King Hawaiians… 😉
Perfect Super -Bowl -Snack! I think the sauce is a great extra touch 🙂
Thanks! Everyone getting pretty amped around here…pretty cool/fun..
YUM! Great tailgating snack!
Indeed…the Niners should have been playing the Pats!
It’s really funny, but I eat very little meat and almost no beef, but this is the kind of Super Bowl item I wouldn’t be able to pass up. They look so good to me! I love the idea of putting them on the King’s Hawaiian Bread rolls. Congratulations on the upcoming anniversary. You’ve completed a lot of work in one year! 🙂
Thanks- you will see a post on the anniversary soon. Time moves fast.
As for the beef. We eat less than you might think, but when we do, we want it to be great. These Sliders qualify…
Darling idea…perfect finger food that sustains the belly. I would add garlic to the beef.
The sauce def sounds better than ketchup or mustard. 🙂
Thanks! The sauce is the secret to the sliders and the Shake Shacks’ burgers…hard to go wrong..
Reblogged this on My Manhattan Kitchen and commented:
Putney Farm has made these sliders look great.
Beautiful! Your sauce looks awesome. One hint, after living in Hawaii, I learned to love those Kings rolls. I even make my own version called aloha rolls. However, when I use them for sliders, I cut a bit out of the middle of the roll, otherwise there is too much bread to meat ratio. Just a thought for you.
A good thought- Thanks!
wooww! i will try this.. they look delicious! 😀
Hope you enjoy them!
Reblogged this on My Meals are on Wheels.
oh, the cheese!
…and the sauce!
I may have asked you this before, but… Do you deliver?
Locally, yes….we charge in cocktails. If we deliver you need to make us a drink, possibly 2.
Thanks for the inspiration. We just made a batch. Awesome. You guys rock!
Cool- glad you enjoyed them!
Reblogged this on CARMEN.
Pingback: Golden Beet Sliders « Putney Farm