Weekly Cocktail #14: The May Daisy

May Daisy Cocktail.

One of the promises we made when we started blogging was to keep ourselves challenged and use the opportunity to try new things. For Carolyn this means new baking techniques, for me it means new tools and ingredients for cooking and cocktails. As for cooking, we always enjoy trying new recipes and the garden is a constant source of inspiration and challenges. But for cocktails, we sometimes find it easy to get “comfortable”. We generally prefer gin, rum and tequila over whiskeys and darker spirits (although we do like our Applejack). And since there are so many cocktail recipes,  it is easy to stay in our comfort zone.

But Carolyn’s recent success with a new baking technique in her Mocha Cake reminded us to try new things and we went right for a big challenge, Cognac-based (or really brandy-based) cocktails. Even more so, a summer cocktail with brandy. For those of you less familiar with brandy, it is simply liquor made with distilled wine rather than sugar or grain. The wine used as the base for brandy can be from any fruit, but is most famously from grapes. Good brandies are made all over the world, pretty much wherever grapes or fruit are grown. But the most famous grape brandies are Cognac and Armagnac from France, and the best bottles are considered some of the greatest spirits in the world.

May Daisy and ingredients.

Most of the best Cognacs and Armagnacs should be enjoyed on their own, but there are many varieties that are good for cocktails. In fact, Cognac was the spirit of choice for many early American cocktails, including the Mint Julep. But outbreaks of Phylloxera in France during the 1800’s limited Cognac supplies and Americans turned more to their native whiskey. But quality Cognac / brandy has good fruit, floral and spice flavors that make it a worthy addition to many drinks.

Cognacs and Armagnacs are both distilled grape wine that’s aged in oak barrels. The main difference in production is their region / appelation and that Cognac is distilled twice, while Armagnac just once. The other difference is price, with Cognac usually 2x the price of Armagnac. While many will argue the relative merits of Cognac vs. Armagnac, the real variables in brandy are aging and blending. To keep it brief (and trust us the French can get into great, laborious detail on these matters) VS is the youngest designation with 2 years of aging, VSOP with 4 years and XO with at least 6 years, but often many more. “Napoleon” is another common designation usually meaning somewhere between VSOP and XO. Simple, huh?

In any event, we can generalize a lot bit and say that most VS Cognac can be harsh, hot and not all that tasty. VSOP bottles are often very good on their own or in cocktails. And XO is usually best on its own.  When buying Cognac or Armagnac, or any brandy, the best path is to ask someone you trust at your Liquor store for a good bottle, give them the likely use and your price range. This is how we were steered to Armagnac, particularly for cocktails. At roughly 1/2 the price of Cognac, you can get a high quality bottle for less money. We got a great Napoleon Armagnac for about $30 and it is very tasty and smooth with good spice and herbal notes.

Armagnac, good stuff and better price.

As for a Cognac cocktail, we tried a few different drinks before finding the May Daisy. The Sidecar was quite good, a classic Champagne Cocktail with 3/4 oz. of Armagnac added was fantastic (more on this one soon). But as we wanted a “summery” cocktail, we looked to the PDT Cocktail Book (one of our faves) and found the May Daisy. A mix of Cognac (or Armagnac), lemon juice, green Chartreuse, simple syrup and a mint garnish, the May Daisy is a great cocktail. The aroma is floral and minty, while the sip features citrus, spice and herb notes with just a touch of heat going down. The May Daisy is surprisingly refreshing and a truly good summer drink. Even (“no brown drinks”) Carolyn enjoyed this one. High praise in these parts.

One last (geeky) note on the nature of how cocktails continue to evolve, and why we should always try new things. The May Daisy is a variant of the Daisy Mae from the Flatiron Lounge in New York. The Daily Mae uses gin, Chartreuse, lemon juice and simple syrup. The Daisy Mae is a variant of the Last Ward Cocktail (rye, Chartreuse, lemon juice, Maraschino) and/or the Last Word (gin, Chartreuse, lime juice and Maraschino). In the end, it seems that when bartenders get a good basic recipe they run with it. And good thing, too. We love Last Word cocktails, so now we are not so surprised that we like the May Daisy. So the next time you may be thinking “I don’t like X”, maybe you should give it a try. It might be built on a solid foundation.

The May Daisy:


  • 2 oz. VSOP or better Cognac or Armagnac
  • 1 oz. lemon juice
  • 3/4 oz. green Chartreuse
  • 3/4 oz. simple syrup
  • 1 sprig of mint for garnish


  1. Combine all liquid ingredients in a cocktail shaker with ice and shake thoroughly. Strain into a wine glass filled with ice and garnish with mint sprig. Serve.

15 thoughts on “Weekly Cocktail #14: The May Daisy

  1. Great review, but you forgot my favorite classic – Stinger: Cognac with white creme de menthe 50/50. Order a pitcher next time you belly up for an aperitif for the group!

  2. This was a wonderfully informative post! I really didn’t know the distinctions in brandy, and this was a great tutorial. The cocktail recipe sounds great. I’ve had Armagnac a couple of times and I enjoyed it. I’d enjoy using it in this cocktail and getting a bit more familiar with it 🙂 Debra

  3. I love Sidecars, and the May Daisy looks great. Cognac isn’t my favourite spirit, but when I started making cocktails, I used it a lot because someone had given me a bottle. The Sidecar was almost my default cocktail – it’s very forgiving on proportions, so you can alter it to your personal preference.

    Where I am, I haven’t seen any Armagnac cheaper than VSOP Cognac. Maybe they only import the expensive stuff here, and the mass production of the top four brands makes them (comparativley) cheaper. So I buy Courvoisier Exclusif VSOP which is about $US35 here, and is kind of designed for mixing. I prefer it to the Remy Martin VSOP, which is the only other one I’ve tried in cocktails, and I’d recommend it to readers, and to you if you want to branch out from the Armagnac (I have only tired little sample sips of Armagnac, so am no expert, but I think it might have quite a different flavour to the cognac).

  4. Pingback: Bonus Cocktail: The “Classic” Champagne Cocktail « Putney Farm

  5. Pingback: Bonus Cocktail: The Orchard Moonraker « Putney Farm

  6. Pingback: Simple Garden Recipes: Apricot Shrub (And a Bonus Cocktail) « Putney Farm

  7. Pingback: Weekly Cocktail #22: The Margaret Rose « Putney Farm

  8. Pingback: Featured Cocktail: The Margaret Rose « The Cocktail Nest

Please Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s