Cocktail DIY: Stocking Your Bar At Home

As we continue our exploration of cocktails, we are often asked “how do you get started at home and what should we buy”? We certainly have our opinions and we will share them, but there are no perfect answers (opinions, comments, disagreements and even outrage are welcome, feel free to share your thoughts!).  But here is how we would get started:

“Short and sweet” version of the home bar.

Here is the “short and sweet” version: Get a bottle of dry gin, a bottle of light rum and a bottle of whiskey (we like rye, but bourbon or Canadian whiskey are good). Get some Angostura and Regan’s Orange bitters, sweet and dry vermouth (nothing fancy) and fresh citrus. Make a few basic syrups with sugar and honey. Get that old cocktail shaker off the shelf (we bet you have one somewhere) and start making drinks. And what can you make? Martinis, Manhattans, Old Fashioneds, Sours and Daiquiris along with dozens of other “classic” cocktails. Go to Cocktail DB to get more ideas based on ingredients in your fridge. You are off and running for about $100 bucks, and if you assume you will get at least 50 cocktails from these three bottles, the average cost per drink is about $2. Not too shabby (to borrow from Adam Sandler).

But what if you want to take it up a notch? For about $250 you can stock a home bar that allows you to build literally hundreds of cocktails and with “professional” results. A few more spirits and bitters, a liqueur or two and a bit of extra gear and you have a “pro” bar at home. So here is the breakdown, with a focus on readily (and nationally) available ingredients:


  • Dry Gin: All sorts of good options here, but stalwarts like Tanqueray, Brokers, Gordon’s and Beefeater are all under $20. If you are a gin fan, there are dozens of good artisan gins to try, usually around $30. And if you just can’t stand juniper, “new world” gins like Hendrick’s (cucumber) and Nolet (floral) focus on other flavors and are good options. Martinis, Rickeys, Gimlets, Sours and Collins’ are all based on gin. Try classics like the Pegu Club or Aviation.
  • Whiskey: We like rye whiskey and suggest Rittenhouse 80 proof for about $20. If you like bourbon, Bulleit at $25 is a good choice, but there are good options around $15. Good for Manhattans, Old Fashioneds and Sours. Try the Daisy Black for a twist on a Whiskey Sour.
  • Light Rum: We suggest El Dorado Light Demerara rum at $15. Great rum at a good price (their Gold rum is also excellent). Bacardi and Brugal are also solid choices. Good for classics like Daiquiris and Cuba Libre, also a component of many tiki drinks.
  • Aged / Dark Rum:  We suggest Barbancourt 4 or 8-year-old and/or Appleton aged rums, about $25 – $30. While very different, both offer the deep, funky sugar and vanilla flavors that make tiki / tropical drinks sing. Great for tiki drinks and for deeper versions of Daiquiris.
  • Tequila: Plenty of good blanco tequilas under $20, just be sure it is 100% agave. We like to use richer-flavored reposado tequila in most drinks and prefer Cazadores, it works in just about everything and is about $25. For most, tequila is still all about Margaritas, but let’s face it, Margaritas still rock. If you are looking to branch-out, try the Ernesto or Chica Facil.
  • Brandy: This is a tough one. Good brandy isn’t cheap and some brands are not widely available. You will need help at your liquor store. VS Cognac is ok, but XO or VSOP will be better but cost over $30. We like Armagnac, and you can get a very good bottle for $30- $35. National brands like Hennessy have VS Cognacs for under $30, domestic brandies will often be less expensive. If you want to make a good Sidecar, you need good brandy. Also, a key ingredient in classic punches, like Chatham Artillery Punch.
  • Vodka: While not a favorite of many cocktail enthusiasts, a lot of people like vodka, and you probably have a bottle somewhere in the house already. Plenty of good options under $20. Cosmopolitans and Lemondrops are good reasons to have some vodka in your bar.
  • Extras: If you want to add-on, blended Scotch, Irish whiskey, Genever (gin in a richer, maltier style), Laird’s Bonded Applejack (apple brandy), Cachaca (Brazilian sugar cane spirit) and Rhum Agricole are all worthy additions to your bar.

Fortified Wines and Liqueurs:

  • Vermouth: Sweet vermouth from Martini and Rossi and Dry vermouth from Noilly-Prat are under $10 and work well for Martinis and Manhattans. For enthusiasts of vermouth-driven cocktails, Dolin sweet and dry vermouths are excellent but $15 – $20. Carpano Antica is great sweet vermouth but almost $30. As vermouth is wine-based, it must be kept in the fridge or will go bad over time. Buy vermouth in the smallest bottles you can. Fresh, cheap vermouth is still better than old, oxidized, expensive vermouth.
  • Liqueurs: We can say with some confidence that orange liqueur (Curaçao and/or triple sec) is the one liqueur you need for a good home bar. You can’t have a real Sidecar or Margarita without orange liqueur. Cointreau is the standard, and it isn’t cheap. But it is good stuff and goes a long way. $25 for a medium bottle, $40 for a large bottle. Pierre Ferrand Dry Curaçao is another good option at $30. Maraschino Liqueur (Luxardo) and Campari are other liqueurs for such classics as the Aviation and the Negroni. Both are about $30. Benedictine is a good match with whiskey and citrus-based cocktails but is expensive at over $30. Absinthe and Green Chartreuse are both good options to explore, but tend to be acquired tastes and can be pricey, at over $40. We suggest Cointreau and perhaps the Maraschino liqueur to start.


  • Bitters: A classic cocktail isn’t really a “cocktail” without bitters. Bitters add a touch of magic and real depth of flavor to most drinks. They are inexpensive and last forever. Angostura Bitters, about $10, is the standard and a must-have. Angostura is available in most supermarkets and liquor stores. Regan’s #6 Orange bitters is a great touch in many classic cocktails and costs about $15.  Other bitters are a matter of taste, but Peychaud’s, Fee’s Old Fashioned and Fee’s West Indian Orange bitters are all about $10 and good choices. Bittermens Tiki and Mole bitters are pricey (over $15) but very good in tiki and classic drinks. Hundreds of custom bitters are now available, most about $10, so this is a great area to play around.
  • Fresh Citrus: Lemons, limes, oranges and grapefruit are all good options. But the lemons and limes are the most popular ingredients. And while technically not citrus, pineapple juice is a popular ingredient for many classics and tiki drinks.
  • Syrups: Simple syrup (1:1 water to sugar), rich simple syrup (2:1 water to sugar) and honey syrup (1:1 water to honey) are the best ways to sweeten drinks. Simply bring sugar or honey and water to a light boil and stir until combined. Cool and use. You can add herbs and spices to any syrup for extra flavor. Homemade grenadine is easy to make and a very tasty addition to many cocktails, it adds a nice red color, too. If you like Tiki drinks, Orgeat (almond flavor) and Falernum (lime and spice) are good syrups to buy at about $10.


  • Cocktail Shaker / Strainer: While most “pros” go with a Boston Shaker (a metal cup and a glass that you seal together) and a strainer, these take some time to learn how to use. Unless you (and your guests) know what you are doing and/or don’t mind cleaning cocktails off your walls, we suggest a cobbler-style shaker. The cobbler shaker has a metal cup with a lid that has a strainer. While it takes a bit more time to strain some drinks, we prefer the cobbler shaker for home use. Both styles of shaker will cost about $10 ( julep or Hawthorne strainers both cost about $5, if you go with a Boston shaker), but before you buy anything look around the house. Cocktail shakers are a popular gift, you (or your friends / relatives) may have one lying around. And as long as it keeps a seal, it’s a good shaker.
  • Mixing Glass: You can simply use a solid pint glass, but a wider mixing glass makes it easier to stir drinks with ice. A basic mixing glass will be $5 – $10, but you can go crazy here and get upwards of $50. Again, you or a friend may have one lying around. Use that or start with a less-expensive option.
  • Jigger Measure: You do need a good jigger measure. Good cocktails require exact measurements. Most jiggers have a 1 and 1/2 oz. side (a jigger) and a 1 oz. (pony) side. Good jiggers show measurements down to the 1/4 oz., these are preferred. Oxo is a good supplier. Expect to pay $5 – $10.
  • Fine Mesh Strainer: For straining little bits of mint, citrus pulp or muddled fruit from drinks. You probably have a small one in your kitchen, and that will work. Otherwise, the cost will be about $5 at a kitchen store.
  • Citrus Squeezer: Another good buy. You can find these in specialty stores or Latin markets. They save a lot of time and (some) mess. Cost is anywhere from $2 – $10. Get a solid squeezer, it will get a lot of use.
  • Barspoon: You can use any long spoon, but a barspoon is helpful for mixing and controlled pouring of ingredients. And it only costs about $2.

So now that you have a well-stocked bar, how do you know what to make? While there are many great cocktail books, we suggest you start with the internet. Here are a few good sites to start with (but there are plenty more, go explore):

  • Cocktail DB: A very thorough database of classic and current cocktails. Sort by name or ingredient.
  • Cocktail Virgin Slut: One of the best blogs to see what new spirits and creations are out there.
  • Serious Eats Drinks: Good cocktail recipes from bars, restaurants and food / spirit writers. In-depth features on spirits and liqueurs.
  • Mixology Monday: A monthly themed “online cocktail party”. Good drinks, but also links to other cocktail sites and blogs.
  • Liquid Culture Project: A deep exploration of both new and old cocktails.
  • Measure and Stir: Cocktail experiments and opinions.
  • Cold Glass: Well researched articles and recipes of classic cocktails. Great photos.
  • Cocktail Chronicles: Mostly inactive, but one of the bellweather cocktail blogs. Great cocktail recipes and detailed recipes for making syrups at home.
  • Boozed + Infused: If you want to make your own boozy infusions or cocktails, Alicia’s excellent site is the place to visit.
  • Alcademics: Camper English’s booze blog and links to his cocktail writing. Good stuff.
  • The Boo Lion: Classic and contemporary cocktails all the way from Taiwan.

And if you read and experiment enough, your bar might fill up a bit…have fun!

56 thoughts on “Cocktail DIY: Stocking Your Bar At Home

  1. The Rittenhouse 100 is a great rye for a great price! I’d also suggest to your readers that if they want a value bourbon to look into the Evan Williams Black Label and/or Old Fitzgerald Bonded (a wheated bourbon). Classic flavors at under $20 each.

    I love your workstation! It’s a wild beauty!

      • Well the most Christmas-y alcohol that comes to mind is bradny so I would do something based on that. I found this recipe for A Single Plum Floating in Perfume Served in a Mans Hat’ this to me is very Christmas-y (There have been 9 votes and a rating of 9 so I think this is probably a good drink though always try it beforehand just to make sure you are happy to serve it to your guests!)Otherwise you could try the colour thing and just choose a cocktail that matches your colour scheme. If you google certain coloured cocktails it will give you plenty of options.

  2. It take some space, products, tools and … a man to be a drink designer. *smile – I have some of this and I’m struggling with space as its. Have a secret compartment in my coffee table for all open bottles. All I need today is .. really Rum – so I can have great Mojito’s. And vodka of course, and whiskey for my friends, and gin .. and calvados… Martell .. and Champagne…. and Baileys and .. Cointreau and Tia Maria .. and Campari … and … and … and … and … and .. and. Brilliant post by the way – some job has gone in to this one.

  3. We always wanted to stock a decent bar and took advantage of a graduation party (mine, rather late in life) to splurge on good bar ingredients. Unfortunately, my friends drank all of the scotch and we had to replace that immediately. Note to self – graduate at the typical age and the loss of an entire fifth of scotch during the course of the evening is less likely than, say, the vodka or tequila. But ok then. It becomes much easier to stock after that first huge purchase, as long as you keep up with it.

    And then the bar itself. Mr. U. calls ours the ‘shrine to ethanol’. Must try some of the orange bitters you reco’d. As you know, we tend to use blood orange bitters and I find them rather sweet overall.

    Also, Mr. U. makes a smashing homemade ginger beer which is great for the odd Moscow Mule or what have you.

    Thanks for the post – it is really hard for people to get started, but you’ve done a great job of selecting items that will give a huge range of options.

    So many drinks, so little liver.

    • Indeed, not enough liver or time to enjoy all the cool stuff out there.

      The Regan’s orange bitters is less sweet and more like spicy, caramelized orange peels. It is a great fit with gin and takes some of the edge off the juniper flavor.

      Thanks for the kind words! And we like “shrine to ethanol”…

  4. Great post! You can bet I’ll come back to it again and again, especially with the holidays coming up – that means parties, and parties mean stocking some of my guest’s favorites.

    I often find myself puzzled in the liquour store staring at the bottles, wondering what is a good buy for something I rarely ever drink and am buying for someone else. (I may be cheap, but that doesn’t mean I want everyone to know it!)

    Now, I’ll have an idea of what is a good value!

  5. Excellent guide. I started with a bottle of Cognac that had been a gift and a bottle of white rum that I’d bought to make Mojitos. The first purchase was a bottle of Cointreau. That was what I had two years ago. I buy a couple of bottles a month and now I have about 60. You don’t have to start ‘all-at-once’.

    You might find this interesting: 3-, 4- and 5-bottle ‘bars’ and some drinks to go with them:

    Oh, and thanks a lot for the link (again)!!! It’s much aprpeciated.

    • Thanks fro the comment and the lick to the article, very cool…

      We started in a similar way…we had some gin and wanted to make more than Martinis, we started with Frech 75s and went from there…after a while you get a decent collection…

  6. Really, a great post. I think people are often intimidated by making cocktails at home and don’t know where to start. Or they know what they like, but haven’t experimented or don’t know what to get for others with different tastes than their own.
    It was nice to see a photo of some of your liquor cabinet too! Thanks so much for the mention. Cheers!

  7. We actually find that splurging on the Vermouths like Antica Carpano is worth it. We have no issues getting through the litre bottle since it’s sippable on it’s own (as well as being an excellent mixer). The only other thing I would add to your list is a small fine mesh strainer – we find it indispensable for citrus and muddled drinks. You can find it for around $2 at restaurant supply stores, or even using a tea leaf strainer works.

  8. Thanks for mentioning the strainer, I will add it to the article…we use one pretty often and they are cheap if you don’t already have one…

    We do like the Carpano as well…good stuff…

  9. Such an informative post and glad to know I’m on the right track with my own bar. I couldn’t help but notice that you didn’t really have recommendations for vodka. I’d like to suggest Tito’s Handmade Vodka, which is actually made in Texas and very affordable. It’s kind of a sleeper as in a lot of people are just starting to know more about it even though it’s been around for a while.

    • Thanks- we are fans of Titos and used it it the Long Island Iced Tea and others (we went with a Stoli bottle because we had it and it “looks” a bit more classic)…

  10. This is so helpful! My husband and I are more “beer and wine” people, but we entertain a lot. And I try to have a well stocked bar for friends. Sometimes I feel a little unsure of how to cover the bases. This is a great reference. Thank you!

    • Thanks for the kind words. We may visit on beer and wine a bit as well (we still like both)… But we find adding cocktails is great for conversation and they taste good…

  11. Pingback: Weekly Cocktail #35: The Diamondback « Putney Farm

  12. Pingback: Holiday Entertaining: Making A List And Checking It Twice « Green Door Hospitality

  13. very good and comprehensive list! i wish i would have read something like this years ago. we really love Old Overholt as an affordable rye whiskey — makes excellent Old Fashioneds! i dont know a thing about tequila, though, so thank you for the advice 🙂

  14. Pingback: A Cocktail For Election Day: The Tammany Jack « Putney Farm

  15. Pingback: Weekly Cocktail #36: A Martini « Putney Farm

  16. Pingback: Five Classic Cocktails for the Young and Fabulous « Wining Wife

  17. Pingback: The Liquid Culture Project

  18. Pingback: The Temperate Zone Cocktail | The Liquid Culture Project

  19. Pingback: What’s in Your Home Bar? « Wining Wife

  20. Pingback: Mixology Monday Cocktail: The McCovey Cove « Putney Farm

  21. Pingback: The Grouse Hunter | The Liquid Culture Project

  22. Pingback: Perfect Manhattan | Norb Vonnegut

  23. Pingback: Weekly Cocktail #38: The Rusty Nail « Putney Farm

  24. Pingback: Sunshine Margaritas. | Sweet Tea and Sunshine

  25. Pingback: Planning Guide for Beverages (Drinks Per Guest) « Best Party & Event Rental

  26. Pingback: *Mixology Monday!* Red & Green Themed Signature Cocktails Special Edition! | My Sweet Wedding Co.

  27. Pingback: Mixology Monday Cocktail: Alone, Bitter at the Beach « Putney Farm

  28. Pingback: The Red Kiss | Gourmet Veggie Mama

  29. Pingback: Beverage Party Planning Guide | Best Party & Event Rental

  30. Pingback: Plums In Rum / Plommer I Rom | RecipeReminiscing

Please Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s