Cocktails for Memorial Day: The Presbyterian / The Mamie Taylor

Mamie Taylor Cocktail. A Presbyterian Cocktail with lime.

More recipes for Memorial Day weekend. The inspiration for these cocktails comes from an odd source, although I guess any cocktail called a Presbyterian has an odd source. The history and traditions of the Presbyterian church are somewhat austere to be the source of many cocktails.

Anyway, it turns out that our local farmers market is near a very popular church. The church is so big they have three services every Sunday morning, which happens to be our farmers market time. Most of the year this isn’t a big deal, but as we get into summer the crowds at the farmers market grow and parking becomes scarce. Tempers can flare a bit (silly, I know, but such is local life) with the crowds and one friend recently remarked “better get there early or you will be chucking elbows with those damned Presbyterians!” Classic.

While we don’t have a dog in that fight, the comment did remind us of the Presbyterian cocktail. We were looking for a summer drink that used whiskey, rather than lighter spirits and the Presbyterian does the trick. The Presbyterian not only uses whiskey, it uses blended scotch, something we don’t often equate with summer. The Presbyterian combines 1 part scotch with 1-2 parts of ginger ale (or ginger beer) served over ice. And it is surprisingly good, particularly if you like scotch or blended whiskey. The sip is refreshing, with a touch of the smoke and peat from the scotch and some sweetness and spice from the ginger ale. The scotch keeps the sweetness in check and provides a clean finish. A good cocktail but perhaps a bit off-beat for some.

Happily, we are just a little lime juice away from the “evolution” of the Presbyterian, the Mamie Taylor. Most cocktail historians agree the Presbyterian was created in the late 1890’s and that by 1900 someone added some lime and called it the Mamie Taylor, and it became a very popular drink. Mamie, it seems, was a famous singer of the time, just not famous enough to leave any other records or herself (heck, maybe she just knew the bartender who created the drink). At least she lives on as a cocktail, and the lime juice certainly makes the Mamie Taylor more approachable and balanced. The lime juice adds the acidity and sour notes that play well with the scotch and ginger ale. This shouldn’t be a surprise, as both the Dark and Stormy and the Moscow Mule are believed to be variants of the Mamie Taylor and both remain popular drinks.

But if you like scotch or whiskey and want a longer, summer drink the Mamie Taylor is certainly worth a try. Even Carolyn said, if you want to serve a “brown drink” make it that one- and that is high praise. We tried The Famous Grouse and Johnny Red as the scotch and both worked well. We also tried using Schweppes ginger ale and Cock and Bull ginger beer and found slight differences in spice, but if you have a ginger ale/beer you prefer, it should work. The recipe also suggests you play around with the volume of ginger ale to suit your tastes, we found 3 oz. to be about right. The big variable is the lime juice, just a little gives balance, add a lot and the scotch becomes a background player.

Some recipes for the Presbyterian and the Mamie Taylor erroneously suggest using rye or blended Canadian whiskey, but we would recommend against it. We tried these recipes with High West Double Barrel rye and it was a bust. Unless you like very, very sweet drinks, the taste becomes downright cloying by the third sip. So in some ways ,the relative “austerity” of the scotch is a better choice, and these cocktails live up to their Presbyterian heritage. Ok, that’s a stretch…but they do taste good.

The Presbyterian:


  • 2 oz. blended scotch whisky
  • 2-4 oz. ginger ale or ginger beer (to taste)


  1. Fill a large highball glass with ice the add the scotch and ginger ale. Gently stir and serve.


The Mamie Taylor:


  • 2 oz. blended scotch whisky
  • 2-4 oz. ginger ale or ginger beer (to taste)
  • 1/2 oz. fresh lime juice
  • Lime wedge for garnish


  1. Fill a large highball glass with ice the add the scotch, ginger ale and lime juice. Gently stir, garnish with lime wedge and serve.

4 thoughts on “Cocktails for Memorial Day: The Presbyterian / The Mamie Taylor

  1. Great! I was reading about the Mamie Taylor in ‘Vintage Spirits and Forgotten Cocktails’ just the other day, and I’ve been quite liking my rum and ginger beer drinks, so this might be a good one to try out more with ginger beer – a great cocktail ingredient. What I’ve learnt is that you really do need to get the right amount of ginger beer, and it’s trial and error because of the different strengths of different products. If the spirit’s not strong enough, too much ginger beer will easily kill it.

  2. You are right about experimenting with the ginger beer, but it is fun work. The real surprise to us is how well the scotch does in a long drink. While bourbon or rye are too sweet, the scotch was just right and the smoke / peat notes blended in. We had a few extra friends try the drink and they liked it, too. This drink may make a “comeback”..

  3. Pingback: Bonus Cocktail: El Diablo « Putney Farm

Please Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s